c3, c3 church, CHC, Christian City Church, City Harvest Church, Kong Hee, Phil Pringle, Pringle, scandal, Sun Ho
Phil Pringle has a problem. His problem is with anger. How do we know this? He has said so himself.
Source: Phil Pringle, “Find Your Flavor” // Phil Pringle // 03.16.14, Vimeo, http://vimeo.com/89512591, PM Service, 16/03/2014. (Accessed 21/03/2014.)
Astonishingly, he stood up in a C3 meeting and said this to his faithful followers. We are not surprised Phil is angry. He’s got so many things to be angry about. What are some of the things he is angry about?
He is angry about the ongoing court case against CHC leaders. He is angry that he is being associated with the scandal, and rightly so. He is angry with the details being splashed across secular and Christian media alike on a regular basis. He is angry that he can’t shut his critics up. And above all, he is angry that the situation is continuing to spiral out of his control.
Phil has a lot to lose as a result of this particular imbroglio, not least of which is his credibility in the eyes of his C3 members all around the world. So, astonishingly the “great apostle of faith ” has feet of clay after all. In an interview with CityNews (part of CHC’s media machine) he gets the opportunity to talk and judge his critics.
Phil had some gratuitous advice for the good people of Singapore. He didn’t want them “destablised by material they read”. He said, ”Experience trumps information every time” – in effect that they should continue throwing money and blowing kisses at Kong Hee and ignore the facts, including Kong Hee’s own admissions.
Anonymous internet critics were singled out by Phil as a “nameless, faceless, spineless group of people who don’t even have the courage or conviction to identity themselves” and hence had no accountability. Apparently anonymity is the reason Phil cannot counteract with critics. However this does not explain why Phil does not do TV interviews when they say “Look we’ve got all these accusations, you should come and make a defense for yourself”.
There are MANY inconsistencies in this interview with Phil Pringle that we hope to address in later articles.
An Interview With Phil Pringle: On Goals, Victory, Truth & The Ultimate Breakfast Partner
Phil Pringle, City Harvest Church’s beloved advisory pastor, shared his goals, workout secrets and his heart for the church in this interview with City News in January this year.
Shorter hair! (laughs) My daughter cuts my hair mostly. She’s a hairdresser.Why do you look younger every time we see you?
Do you go for any treatments?
No! (laughs) I work out an hour a day, six days a week. Sometimes it’s more than an hour. At the gym, I do a spin class for one hour, then I do at least half an hour of weights, and I call them prime exercises: pushups, chin-ups, squats, all of that. Just so long as I’m stiff. Gotta be stiff in some area of my body all the time, otherwise I’m not working out properly. I walk every morning for an hour as well, just in prayer. But I don’t consider that a workout.
You spoke to CHC about the “unshakeable church” in 2014. What are your personal goals for this year?
I kinda don’t do resolutions and goals. I know I tell everybody else to. (smiles) I live by sort of a set of general principles: To write one book a year. To maintain my weight. To reduce debt. To improve all relationships.
In terms of church goals, we’re aiming to have 10 campuses around the city—we’re starting 3 on Feb 23. Our aim is to have 20 campuses all up in the city of Sydney of our church. We’ll start about another 100 churches around the world this year. We aim to fill the entertainment center for Presence—12,000 seats. Just for our church to keep growing and be healthy.
Are there new C3 churches around the world?
In Australia we just started one in Noosa a while ago — that’s already up to about 150 people. We combined one in New Zealand, in Christchurch. It has about 700 to 800 people.
We’re just starting one in Cronulla in Sydney on 23 Feb. We started one in Brooklyn with George Kelsey, it’s going very well. We started one in Silicon Valley with a young guy named Malcolm—that’s going very well. There’ll be a whole lot in Africa that I don’t know about—that’s our fastest growing region.
About 10 churches joined us in the UK in the last six months. They’re really great churches. They’d been coming to our conferences, and they like our style and what we’re doing. They weren’t enjoying where they were, didn’t want to stay independent, became part of what we’re doing. It’s great.
At your last service here, you said “2014 adds up to 7”.
Did I get it right?
(laughs) Yes! Are numbers significant?
I think numbers are significant but I don’t think they have magical properties. So I would stop short of numerology. Some people think incantations with numbers are going to make a difference. I don’t subscribe to that. But I do think that numbers are very significant throughout Scripture. The study of numbers in Scripture is astonishing. God works in time—7 days. I think you gotta stop short of becoming superstitious. So if your birthday falls on Friday the 13th … I don’t think you should think that’s a problem.
What has God spoken to you about this year?
What He’s saying to me may not be what He’s saying to everybody. In terms of church growth, I feel He is wanting a more organic approach to worship and fellowship in church life. So we’ve started some more services in our church that are quite small services. One is a chapel service, only goes for one hour, it’s got no drums. It’s quite calm, it’s got a harp and acoustic guitars. And we’re trying to reach seniors but we’re finding all kinds of people are coming too. It’s packed out, absolutely jammed. The hall can take 200 people, but it’s jammed. We do another one on Saturday night—it’s become popular for young families.
I would think that the whole marketplace initiative and the arts being engaged will become increasingly more so. I also think that opposition will increase. I don’t think the Internet attacks and haters are going to lessen, they’ll increase, but I think that they’ll become passé. People will realize that these are people who are not well and are better to be ignored. But they definitely have had an influence on a lot of people. It makes pastors fight for their purpose and their people when they realize that there are voices out there that are trying to steal their people and influence their minds and hurt what they’re doing, what God’s called us to do.
One of the reasons I spoke on that (at CHC’s service) is so that it will firm up this church. So that people aren’t destabilized by material they read. God’s people are like sheep: the same trust and belief that gets them saved can be taken advantage of by the devil to destabilize them.
All I’m trying to be is a stabilizing influence. So that saints don’t get knocked around. Once they start moving from one church to another, it becomes a pattern, and in a few years they go to no church at all.
How do you help those who are reading the papers, going on the Internet? What about the mainstream papers? Should they read that?
I think you’ve got to make your mind up that it doesn’t affect you. If it affects you, then don’t read it. A child can’t eat steak, so if he can’t chew through the meat, [he shouldn’t] eat it. I don’t read stuff. I used to, but it affected me so badly—and I’m a strong Christian—but because it was about me and my family, and they were all lies. And you’ve got no way of counteracting them.
It’s a criminal act to assassinate someone’s character and not be accountable, to be anonymous. So we’re living with a nameless, faceless, spineless group of people who don’t even have the courage or conviction to identity themselves, while we’re up here—you see my face, you know my name, you have all the numbers to use. The idea these Internet haters have that “I’m protecting myself and my family”—what from? If you’re doing the right thing you have nothing to fear. I knowwe’re doing the right thing.
What can we do to help those who can be shaken by what they read?
Bring them to church. Let them feel the love and acceptance. Experience trumps information every time. And you know the sad thing about that is that there are false religions that have capitalized on that and given people a great experience. And people who have never been loved or welcomed or accepted find love and acceptance, and they will swallow anything to be accepted. It’s not enough to be sincere and believe. Once you get the three together—sincerity, belief and truth—you’ll have a really solid Christian.
And I honestly believe it’s your connection with Christ that’s the most enduring reality. Because most of my contemporaries are not around anymore—I know two from when I was born again who are still following Christ who are still growing today. That’s out of hundreds and hundreds of people.
So as time passes you realize it’s a long road, and to keep walking takes a lot of invisible forces from God on your life. If you are praying and keeping a relationship with Christ alive, He’ll keep you. There’s a verse that says “Keep yourself in the love of God” and immediately following that it says “Now to Him who is able to keep you from falling”. So if you keep yourself in God, He’ll keep you from falling. (Jude 1:21, 24-25)
I would say I have seen more miracles in what God disallows and doesn’t let happen, tragedies that didn’t transpire, than I have where things happened. Man, those times when things could have happened. That was God.
You can’t comment on the trial but have you been keeping abreast of what’s happening?
I read a blog by a woman—Sanses. She was very positive towards the church. I thought she did a really good job. I thought it’s so simple, like man-on-the-street talk. She’s going like, “What am I missing here? The church invested $25m, and now it’s got it all back with interest. Church didn’t lose any money, what am I missing? Why are these people in court?” I probably was doing a search for something when I found it. I thought well, this is good news.
I found one, my daughter did, called C3 Chookwatch. It’s great, it’s for us (C3). I don’t know who he is. His site is called C3 Churchwatch Watch [C3 Churchwatch is an anti-C3 Church website]. “I’m watching the watchers.” He has gone through and cited all these events that C3 Churchwatch has mentioned. Like when (C3 church leader) Mark Kelsey got up and said “Any woman that wants to get another woman to the woman’s conference, buy them a ticket, this woman will come along and get revived”, you know, it’s just nice. On C3 Churchwatch, it says “C3 now believes you can buy revival”. Chookwatch is going “Honestly, if you believe that’s what Mark Kelsey was trying to say, you honestly are very sick.” That’s what I mean, these people are not well. What weird thing would make you say that’s what that means?
Churchwatch has a comparison between Phil Pringle and Jim Jones. “Jim Jones: Lots of people. Phil Pringle: Lots of people.” (snickers) I’m going like, you have got to be kidding me!
But like you say, they affect people. So I tell them, don’t read the stuff, not going to help you.
What about mainstream press?
I think it’s worth knowing what the mainstream press is saying—I certainly stay abreast of it. I think it’s great you’ve got City News, putting out their unabashed version—they still do a pretty good job.
What about TV interviews? You have done a few.
Pretty much I say no to them all now, because it’s a very boring agenda. Unless I really have to. If I really feel like I’ve got to. They usually come and say “Look we’ve got all these accusations, you should come and make a defense for yourself”. I go, “Everyone will have forgotten about this in two days’ time.”
That’s the trouble with the Internet: it’s there all the time. But with television, it’s gone pretty much in a few days.
For television, they’ve generally got an agenda. It’s fairly predictable. They want to create conflict because there’s no news without conflict. So my idea is just to be like Nehemiah and say “No, I can’t come down from this great work. Come to the plain of Ono.” Have you read that? It’s a hilarious name. (chuckles)
You talked about breakthrough and victory for CHC. What do you think that’s going to be?
I can’t comment on the trial. But what I would like to think the victory would be a dropping of the case. All charges dropped, like they were against Sun. So it can happen—it’s happened for her. (The Commissioner of Charities lifted his suspension of Sun Ho from her executive position in CHC in May 2013.)
But I’m not the court, I’m not the judge. I said to our church recently, I believe as Christians we should not abandon our friends in times of crisis. That’s our job. That’s why we are involved—Pastor Kong and Sun are our friends, not only them but this whole church. I’ve been involved in this church since it began, I’m not about to walk away because you guys are facing some challenges.
But that means I take hundreds of other churches, thousands of other people with me where I go. So I have to be mindful of that as well. If I put myself in a predicament, then they’ll have to defend that predicament in their locale. Over in Africa, up in Europe, they’ll be saying, “What’s Phil Pringle doing involved in this?” So I have to let them know that we will let the courts of Singapore decide the rights and wrongs, that’s not our job to be the judges.
Even though I have no reason to believe there is intentional wrongdoing. Or any kind of wrong activity. I would not be involved if I knew there was intentional wrong because association and engagement is tacit endorsement, basically. And that’s where I’ve had to clarify the line and say, “Look I can’t say I know everything, but I do know that what we’re meant to do as Christians is lay down our lives for one another and love each other, that’s what I’m doing. I don’t care what it takes.”
There’s not a lot of ways I can be a Christian. I’m a preacher, I’m a minister. I sometimes think I should go down and give blankets to the homeless and buy pizza for every homeless person, get a little vanload of people. The Lord says to me, look you’ve got a church full of people who can do that. What you can do is something they can’t do: you can help ministers who are under attack and in trouble.
So I’ve done that each year. I’ve reached out to ministers who are in trouble. And some of the times, we’re successful. We’re seeing some restored. It’s not normally this kind of situation. That’s me being a Christian in my world, you know what I mean?
You told the congregation about how you dug deep when you sought the truth as a young Christian. How do we get people to “dig deep”?
We should have a quest for truth. Truth is too important to say, “Well, I’ll deal with that later after I watch TV.” I mean, honestly, this is about eternity. It’s all pretty serious. I just want people to make it, I want them to make it to the finish line. If they get tossed about by every wind and doctrine, they may not make it. So I think you’ve got to have a personal love for the truth. In the Bible it says in the last days, man will not be lovers of the truth. To be a lover of truth is to want to know Christ.
As leaders how do we help them?
It’s a good question: you’ve got to whet people’s appetite. I think if you can get a person to study one subject for half an hour in the Bible. If you sit with them and teach them how to study, and they start to read it and meditate upon it, they start to have an experience. The Bible is an experience. And once they have that experience, they’ll start to pant for the word of God. Not just to read it for inspiration, but to read it for understanding and knowledge.
I’ve been asking myself a similar question. How do you get people to do things they don’t want to do? Reason is because I’m a pretty willing, eager, involved person. So when people ask me to do something, I say sure, I’ll get involved. But there are a couple of things recently people have been asking me, and I didn’t really want to do them, but I did them. But I had excuses, I didn’t have a lot of energy, I didn’t last long. I got out of the whole thing pretty quick. I went away thinking, what could they have done to make me want to be there and to really get into it?
The first thing I thought about was responsibility. If they’d said, “Why don’t you carry all the fishing gear?” (because one of the things was to do with fishing. I’m not really into fishing at all.) You’re not enjoying it, you leave early, you make excuses, and it doesn’t work anyway, you don’t catch anything, ‘cause you’re not into it. So I went away thinking, there’s a lot of people like that that I’m leading. They’re doing it because I’m asking them to, they’re not into it.
So how do you do that? If someone had said, “You drive the boat” or “You are responsible for carrying all the gear”, instead of doing the tag-along thing, they give you a responsibility, then you get involved and you’ve got something to do. I think if they were to do it with you, you know, then it becomes obligating to one another.
If you’re standing at the back of the boat and you’ve only got one fishing rod, and he says, “Okay, you put it in” and he really gets involved with you (makes motion of holding fishing rod), then bzzzzz(mimicks line moving), “You got that? Now we’re going to pull gently, reeling him in.” You then get the feeling of catching a fish and you think “Wow, this is good.” But when you’re sitting in the back and they’re all talking among themselves ignoring you, you think, “I so want to get off this boat.”
So, I think we’ve got to figure out how we get people’s hearts, not just their obedience.
You called the church to make Jesus the chief cornerstone. Does that mean there are churches that don’t make Him the chief cornerstone?
Churches are built around a variety of things. Sometimes it’s in the name of the church—“we’re the church of this and this”—and because they’ve defined themselves so clearly, it actually defines that Jesus is not. But sometimes that would be true. I think churches are better to be less clearly defined by doctrine or by anything else other than Christ. And only Jesus knows if He is the center of a church. But if He is the center, then the branches will be bearing fruit.
Final question: If you could have breakfast with a hero of faith from the Bible, who would it be and why?
David. I’d like to know how he saw God like he did under Old Testament conditions. Because he’s the only one who really has that New Testament revelation of God. He gets right into an intimate personal relationship with God. I identify with David in a lot of ways: his creativity, his musicianship, his writing, the warrior thing, the leadership thing, the discipling thing, the youthful thing.
Source: By Theresa Tan, An Interview With Phil Pringle: On Goals, Victory, Truth & The Ultimate Breakfast Partner, CityNews, http://www.citynews.sg/2014/03/an-interview-with-phil-pringle-on-goals-victory-truth-the-ultimate-breakfast-partner/, Added on March 7, 2014. (Accessed 26/03/2014.)
Hey Phil!!! Howzit old mate?
Well I think you were quoting me here:
The idea these Internet haters have that “I’m protecting myself and my family”—what from?”
Well Phil – I’m protecting myself from the barrage of “Hi Simeon, how you doing? Do you want to come along to young families this week?”, or “do you want to meet up?” – where I know I will get questioned, ridiculed, possibly threatened with legal action. When my kids go to the same school as the pastor’s kids’ kids, I’ve witnessed how fast rumours can spread. I don’t want my children to be singled out because of standing up for the truth.
You want me to identify yourself? Sure, if you want! The other problem is it will also expose others who have had a gutfull of the way the whole business, sorry, organisation is run. Actually maybe they will publish their names too – and say how sick of the tripe they are.
Phil – do those articles hurt you, and me? Yes! They hurt me, because it’s about people I know and trust like G. Moore (I know most people here don’t agree but hey). Other ex-c3 pastors not mentioned here but got burned out. But do I run away and backslide? No! I press on to get deeper into the truth of the Gospel, and into living a holy life – not giving more to build a bigger building.
Phil – do you honestly expect anyone, except CHC to believe that interview?
I think you are angry, and scared – not because people are against you per se, but the massive empire is on the edge. Who you have supported, the doctrine that’s preached. I pray you then back to the solid foundation of the Christian faith before it’s too late.
Oh sorry that was meant to say “do you want me to identify *myself* ”
…which if I did, I’m sure others would come out publicly about how they’ve been treated etc.
I don’t normally write in CAPS, but here we go:
Phil – your comment about Sanses’ blog…
WHAT ARE YOU THINKING???!!!
DELIBERATELY INTERFERING WITH COURT PROCEEDINGS?!
YOU HAVE DESTROYED YOUR CREDIBILITY, SHOT YOURSELF IN THE FOOT AND POTENTIALLY JEOPARDISED YOUR MATE WALKING FREE!!!
This person pringle has completely lost it.quote: “But that means I take hundreds of other churches, thousands of other people with me where I go”. [Where are YOU going phil? Heaven or Hell?] “People will realize that these are people who are not well..”
You mean like Phil and chris Pringle who did every kind of drug and really believe it isn’t a LSD flashback? Scientists have proved that if you do enough drugs like PCP [Phil Chris Pringle..a coincidence?] and LSD it stays in your brain FOREVER. C3 people please recognise that these NZ imports have been ‘snared’ by MONEY and have taught their kids to love MONEY and what it can bring them.They are NOT Christian royalty..but another breed of false prophets and wolves ready to take your money. Be VERY wary that your ‘tithe’ is actually promoting this vain imaginative Lawlessness.
“I do a spin class for one hour”. He certainly knows how to spin.
Have no problem with Pringle supporting Hee as a friend. Regardless of what happened, Hee would need spiritual and emotional help. It’s Pringle as the head of C3 Church taking all of C3 with him in support, and his seemingly thinking there is not and has never been a problem.
“I do a spin class for one hour”.
We were wondering who was going to point that out.
“I found one, my daughter did, called C3 Chookwatch. It’s great, it’s for us (C3). I don’t know who he is.”
what? is pringle endorsing a CRITIC that he doesn’t know? if he doesn’t know them, doesn’t that mean pringle thinks they are a “nameless, faceless, spineless” critic?
it makes no sense why pringle would endorse someone he doesn’t know. what pastor would do that?
The church invested $25m, and now it’s got it all back with interest. Church didn’t lose any money, what am I missing?
Love the logic. So I can break into his house -> steal $100k -> take it to the casino & put it all on black -> win-> return $100k and keep the winnings without fear of prosecution. No money was lost right? Even if I lose, I’ll double-up and repeat until I win!
Set Free said:
Wow, now all pastors can do that. Use money from the church accounts illegally,then if caught, undo the theft by returning the money and better still share some of the profit you made (if any) with the church. Then everything will look neat and nice and only the pharisees like C3 churchwatch will insist you stole money.
Talk about a lack of insight!!!! OK young woman – imagine yourself in a similar situation. Without your consent someone empties your bank account. You with the help of the police track down the culprit and *only then* does that person decide to fully reimburse you.
Ask yourself – would you really say OK, he /she returned the money so I should forgive them and prevent them from getting a criminal record/ sentence?!!!
To quote an old c3 song,
“Fight the fight of faith, taking ground at your command….”
Apply that to this – at Phil’s command.
I remember that song. Off the Contact album.
Sorry about my myriad of replies…
On the other side of the coin re the C3CWW author PP ‘doesn’t’ know about – I’d like to know who (or at least the level of leadership) that is leaking info from Oxy.
Unfortunately since banishing C3 from the orchestra of my life, I don’t have an insider anymore, so I am unable to gain information.
“I’d like to know who (or at least the level of leadership) that is leaking info from Oxy.”
LOL: not as much as Phil Pringle would like to know. Apparently that place is continuing to leak like a sieve, and the “prophetic powers” of the pastors there don’t run to identifying spies and turncoats.
I’ve never seen C3OF referred to as “Oxy” – I guess we could say that the place is run by “Oxy Morons” …
The whole issue with CHC is that they are accused by the Singapore Govt of taking the money from a ” Regulated” CHC fund to fund Kong Hee’s wife’s rock star career and they tried to hide the transactions she lived a movie star lifestyle in Hollywood they are accused of spending Church members hard earned funds for their benefit , NO TRANSPARENCY!! NO ACCOUNTABILITY!! and when they got caught with their fingers in the lolly jar they are accused of doing some dodgy sham transactions to make it look as though they paid it back, the money it seems was spent on a dodgy China Wine video clip, (which I would not dare to show my kids as its too sexual) expensive Hollywood accommodation, lots of staff in Hollywood , expensive airfares production costs for the music , you name it they spent money on it !! And still Ps Pringle and other C3 senior pastors have the hide to allow him come back and speak at Presence 2014 all I can say is, anyone who donates their money to these guys is nuts !!! And Pringle’s interview is again just spin,spin,spin!! He refuses to tell C3 Church members the truth about CHC and the disgraceful situation in Korea regarding his long time so called mentor David Yonggi Cho, who has many more accusations against him made by his church elders he has yet to answer for , yes folks wait for it there is more grubby news to come out of Korea. Its like watching a slow motion train wreck !!